He immediately reveals it was all a lie to mock her gullibility, referring to her feelings as a "monkey show".
Some critics from Moe Sucks and Reddit argue the episode is "textbook emotional abuse," finding Erika's persistent devotion to Kyouya after such cruelty to be "pathetic" or "misogynistic".
Other fans on RABUJOI highlight the episode's speed, noting that the show reaches significant romantic milestones much faster than typical shoujo anime. The Conclusion: A "Wolfish" Apology Ookami Shoujo to Kuro Ouji Episode 5
Erika’s rare moment of standing up for herself—throwing water in Kyouya's face and storming out—is often cited by reviewers as a necessary and satisfying high point. Mixed Critical Reception
The episode centers on Erika's desire to spend a romantic Christmas with Kyouya, which leads to a devastating fake confession. He immediately reveals it was all a lie
Watch this breakdown to see how the reconciliation at the end of the episode leaves a lasting impression on viewers:
Episode 5 of Ookami Shoujo to Kuro Ouji (Wolf Girl and Black Prince) is a high-stakes emotional turning point that many viewers found simultaneously sweet and frustratingly toxic. The Conclusion: A "Wolfish" Apology Erika’s rare moment
The episode ends with a reconciliation that shifts the tone back to shoujo sweetness. Kyouya visits Erika’s home and gives her a heart-shaped necklace, effectively "marking" her as his again. While he doesn't explicitly apologize, many viewers saw this act as his unique way of making amends and showing he does value her.