[s1e20] What Is And What Should Never Be ✦ Premium & Plus

While hunting a (a genie-like creature), Dean Winchester is attacked and transported into a "wish-fulfillment" alternate reality. In this world: Mary Winchester (his mother) is alive and well.

, and Sam and Dean are estranged, barely speaking to one another. [S1E20] What Is And What Should Never Be

(his father) died peacefully of a stroke a year prior, rather than being killed by demons. While hunting a (a genie-like creature), Dean Winchester

"Supernatural" What Is and What Should Never Be (TV ... - IMDb (his father) died peacefully of a stroke a

Michelle Borth appears as Carmen, Dean’s girlfriend in the alternate reality. Trivia & Lore

" What Is and What Should Never Be " is a landmark episode of the series Supernatural , specifically serving as . Directed by series creator Eric Kripke in his directorial debut, it is widely considered one of the show's most emotionally profound chapters. Episode Summary