According to reviewers on IMDb , the episode is praised for its complexity, though some viewers found the high frequency of "red herrings" and murky motives slightly contrived. Fans of the Ann Cleeves novels note that the show captures the atmospheric, moody landscape that is as much a character as the detectives themselves.
Known for her disheveled appearance and sharp, calculating mind, Vera excels at spotting small discrepancies in the "tales" people tell to hide their pasts.
The tragic death of an innocent woman (Jeannie) serves as the driving force for the episode, highlighting the devastating consequences of a rushed or flawed original investigation. Critical Reception